AskDrHelen.com


Helen Pensanti, M.D.

Quick Order Natural Hormones Dr. Pensanti Interview with John R. Lee M.D.

Why Natural Progesterone is better than Synthetic

by Jim Paoletti RPh

I am often asked about the statement “she doesn’t need progesterone if she doesn’t have a uterus.” It’s hard to conceive that medical schools are still teaching the idea that a woman without a uterus does not need progesterone. It’s also hard to believe that large number of practitioners consider this statement true, since it is not supported by physiology, biochemistry or science.

Synthetic progestins do not have the same actions as progesterone outside of the uterus. In fact, medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA), the most frequently prescribed synthetic progestin in the U.S., produces the exact opposite effects of endogenous progesterone in almost all, if not all, organs or systems outside of the uterus. The drug first given to us to mimic the effects of natural progesterone works only like progesterone in one organ and everywhere else produces the exact opposite effect of progesterone!

This misguided philosophy results in practitioners not giving progesterone or progestins to patients who have had a hysterectomy, and therefore practitioners never see a direct comparison of the effects of the two different agents on the rest of the body. The above statement helps to keep practitioners from comparing the known proven effects of progesterone on many body systems to the results caused by administration of the “progesterone-mimicking” synthetic progestins. If practitioners would look at the lack of science behind the statement, and the body of evidence supporting overall health benefits of progesterone itself, synthetic progestin use would most likely plummet.

Limiting the use of progesterone to women who have a uterus ignores the science that progesterone has beneficial effects outside of the uterus. Progesterone receptors have been identified in almost every cell in the body; therefore, progesterone has functions throughout the entire body. A quick look at the evidence shows many favorable effects of progesterone, whereas MPA produces unwanted side effects or risks which are the exact opposite of the actions of progesterone.

Breast cancer risk is a chief concern for the majority of women considering hormone replacement therapy. Evidence overwhelmingly shows that any synthetic progestin use, even for a limited time, increases the risk of breast cancer. The longer the use of progestin, or the more testosterone-like the synthetic progestin, the greater the risk becomes. The studies may disagree on how high the risk increase is, but they all agree that synthetic progestins significantly increase the risk of breast cancer. The mechanisms have been identified for the most part, and they are opposite to the mechanisms of endogenous progesterone in breast tissue.

In opposition to the increased risk of synthetic progestins, bioidentical progesterone has been shown to possess anti-proliferative and anti-cancer properties. A low level of endogenous progesterone is associated with an increased risk of breast cancer. Clinical studies suggest progesterone therapy protects against breast cancer. Some studies have even shown a decreased risk of breast cancer when natural progestin is added to estrogen therapy.

Speroff’s textbook, Clinical Gynecologic Endocrinology and Infertility, states that the proliferative action of estrogens and the progesterone actions of differentiation and apoptosis are the same in the breast tissue as in the uterus. Therefore, progesterone, and only progesterone, can protect the breast tissue from cancer by the same mechanism that any progestin protects the uterus. Looking at the science, the above statement needs to be modified to “she doesn’t need progesterone if she doesn’t have a uterus or breasts.”

The number one killer of women over the age of 50 is cardiovascular-related events. MPA has been shown to completely negate the favorable effects of estrogen on the maintenance of a healthy lipid profile and the cardiovascular benefits of estrogen, and significantly increase cardiovascular risks. In contrast, progesterone works synergistically with estrogen to increase lipid maintenance and cardiovascular health. Based on the difference between MPA and progesterone, the writers of the largest hormone study at its time, the 1995 PEPI study, concluded that “we should be giving woman natural progesterone” (this conclusion has still to be incorporated into mainstream medicine). Based on the evidence, the statement needs to be modified to “she doesn’t need progesterone if she doesn’t have a uterus, breasts or a cardiovascular system.”

Other major health concerns for the aging female patient are the development of osteoporosis and dementia. Progesterone works synergistically with estrogen to provide better bone remodeling through stimulation of bone growth, while progestins do not. While progesterone provides neuroprotective benefits for the nervous system, side effects of synthetic progestins are the opposite. Now we need to correctly state, “she doesn’t need progesterone if she doesn’t have a uterus, breasts, a cardiovascular system, bones, or a brain!”

Additional evidence continues to demonstrate the opposite effects of progesterone vs. the synthetic substitutes. MPA is proliferative and inflammatory; progesterone has been demonstrated to be neutral or slightly anti-inflammatory and anti-proliferative in its actions. Progesterone is the drug of choice for protection from further damage in traumatic brain injuries, and in at least two small studies progesterone has been shown to help reverse the debilitating effects of brain injury. MPA causes degenerative changes in the liver, while progesterone does not. Physiologic levels of progesterone augment the release of insulin from the pancreas, while synthetics increase insulin resistance.

The evidence clearly indicates that bioidentical progesterone provides a number of protective benefits not offered by synthetic progestins. Synthetic progestins instead increase risks associated with loss of these protective benefits. Therefore, I would recommend that our health professional educators examine the evidence and teach what the scientific evidence demonstrates: a woman does not need a progestin if she does not have a uterus, but she requires progesterone when it becomes deficient in perimenopause to continue to provide protection of her breasts, heart, blood vessels, bones, nervous system muscles, liver, skin, and perhaps much more yet to be discovered.

Cordially,

Helen Pensanti M.D.

Research Info Archives

  1. 3 Major Health Problems
  2. 5 Ways to Lose Body Fat
  3. 7 Edible Weeds
  4. 7 Steps to Healing
  5. 10 Foods You Should NEVER EAT!!
  6. 10 Things You Must Do To Beat Breast Cancer Now
  7. 10 Ways to Increase Energy
  8. Acne
  9. Age Spots
  10. Alzheimer's Prevention Plan
  11. Aloe Vera Freeze Dried Capsules and AloeVera Liquid Concentrate
  12. Anti-Aging Tips
  13. Anxiety and Stress
  14. Arteries Clean
  15. Arthritis
  16. Atherosclerosis
  17. Baby Boomers and Alzheimer’s Disease
  18. Bacteria and Viral Infections
  19. Bananas are healthy!
  20. Beating Breast Cancer with Nutrition
  21. Belly Fat
  22. Beta Glucan
  23. Beauty of Mathematics
  24. Bio-Identical VS Synthetic Hormones
  25. Bladder Infection Help - Parsley Tea
  26. Blood Clots
  27. Breast Cancer Inducing Chemicals
  28. Breast Cancer Profile
  29. Breast Cancer and Synthetic Hormones
  30. Buying and Preparing Fresh Fish
  31. Cancer Prevention Tips - Stay Cancer Proof
  32. Cancer Protection List - Household Items to Avoid
  33. Cataracts
  34. Chelation Therapy
  35. Clustered Water/Healthy Immune System
  36. Cold Sores
  37. Constipation
  38. Cortisol and Weight Loss
  39. Calories and Calore Counting
  40. Cystitis
  41. Dark Spots On Bananas - Anti Cancer
  42. Date Rape Drug Information - GHB
  43. Dental Problems
  44. Diabetes
  45. Diabetes Mellitus
  46. Diabetes Travel Tips
  47. Diseases Do Not Just Happen
  48. Dr Helen's 1200 Calorie Diet to lose 45 pounds in 3 months
  49. Eating Genetically Modified Fruits
  50. Eliminate "White Poison" From Your Diet
  51. Estrogen Found in Foods/Herbs/Drugs/Chemicals
  52. Estrogen Inhibiting Foods
  53. Fatigue
  54. Fatigue and Loss of Energy
  55. Five Keys to Restoration
  56. Food Toxins
  57. Foot Health
  58. General Question About Natural Hormones
  59. Hair growth in unwanted places
  60. Hair Loss
  61. Headache Check Lists - Headache Symptoms and Headache Causes
  62. Healing properties of garlic and onions
  63. Healing / Water Clusters
  64. Health Updates
  65. Healthly Foods Chart for Bone Health
  66. Healthly Foods Chart
  67. Healthy Food List
  68. Healthy Living Recipe Options
  69. Heart Disease - #1 Cause of Death In America
  70. Heart Disease and Women - Estrogen does not benefit the heart.
  71. High Blood Pressure - Hypertension
  72. Hepatitis
  73. Highlights from Dr Abraham's interview at the 6th Annual Anti-Aging Conference
  74. Holiday Meals
  75. Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) linked to Hearing Loss
  76. Hormone Studies
  77. Inflammation Reduction
  78. Insomnia Information
  79. Keeping Your Liver Healthy
  80. Laser Vision Correction
  81. LeAine Dehmer Clinical Skincare Specialist Answers Your Questions
  82. Long Life and Aging
  83. Lose 45 Pounds In 3 Months
  84. Mamograms - Infrared Thermography
  85. Managing Lactose Intolerance
  86. Mascular Degeneration
  87. Men and Progesterone
  88. Men's Prostate Health
  89. Microbes in an overweight body are more efficient at extracting calories from food.
  90. Mind Boosters
  91. Natural Cancer Treatments
  92. Natural Progesterone and Blood Pressure/Inflammmation
  93. Non Toxic Hair Dyes
  94. Olive Leaf Extract
  95. Organic Dark Unprocessed Chocolate
  96. Osteoarthritis and Musculoskeletal Health
  97. Osteoporosis Prevention
  98. Osteoporosis - Softening of the Bones
  99. Overcoming Anxiety and Depression without Drugs!
  100. Parasitic Infections
  101. Parkinson's Desease
  102. Prostate Cancer & PC Spes
  103. Purify your Home without Poisons Chemicals
  104. Red Clover; Health Benefits of Isoflavones
  105. Phosphatidylserine (PS)
  106. Potassium In The News
  107. Preserving Your Sight
  108. Progesterone - Calming Effects
  109. Progesterone and Breast Cancer Study
  110. Progesterone, can we use that name?
  111. Progesterone, does it build up in your fat cells?
  112. Progestin VS Natural Progesterone
  113. Phyto-Progesterone is now called Diosgenin
  114. Recommended Supplements for Anti-Aging
  115. Seasonal Affective Disorder
  116. Seasonal Allergies
  117. Secret Remedies
  118. Shaping Children's Eating Habits
  119. Signs of Estrogen Deficiency
  120. Signs of Estrogen Excess
  121. Signs of Progesterone Excess
  122. Sinus Problems
  123. Six Types of Mothers
  124. Soy Foods May Protect the Body from Cancer
  125. Symptoms of Low Thyroid
  126. Synthetic Hormones and Breast Cancer
  127. Testosterone - how women can increase or decrease Testosterone Levels
  128. Thinning Hair
  129. Tinnitus
  130. Tips for Traveler's Health
  131. Top Ten Reasons to Get Off Synthetic Hormones
  132. Toxic Shampoos
  133. Type II Diabetes - Insulin Resistance
  134. Vaginal Dryness - High In Oxalate Foods to Avoid
  135. Vitamin A
  136. Vitamin B
  137. Vitamin Bible and Healthy Tips
  138. Vitamin D - emphasizing the importance of supplementing with Vitamin D
  139. Vitamin E - may provide women with protection from breast cancer
  140. Vitamin K
  141. Ways to fit fiber in your diet
  142. Weight Loss
  143. Wellness Plan
  144. West Nile Virus
  145. What to look for in a Biological Dentist
  146. Why Natural Progesterone is better than Synthetic
  147. Women and Heart Disease
  148. Word... Water... Walk...
  149. Wyeth Pharmaceutical lies in study

Home ¦ Contact Dr Helen ¦ Natural Hormone Comparison Chart ¦ Helen Pensanti M.D. Products

Accept Credit Cards